Invited to the Feast, but Refuse to Come

My Dear Parishioners,

This week we hear the fate of those who are invited to the Feast, but refuse to come. Those who “refuse to come” should remind us of those who no longer practice their Catholic Faith. However, this is not just a Catholic problem, but a problem for all Christian Churches. Across all Christian denominations, people are increasingly refusing to come.

A few years ago, I read a book titled The Great Dechurching by Jim Davis and Michael Graham (Zondervan Reflective Publishers, 2023). The authors are Evangelical Protestant pastors from Orlando, Fl. They began to notice their own pews becoming emptier and emptier on the average Sunday. Yes, they were noticing empty pews in Evangelical Parishes in the South.

So, they commissioned a scientific study to find out why this was happening and to find out if anything could be done to reverse the trend. The book is a summary of the findings and is full of statistics, and as they say, statistics don’t lie.

The study not only examined Evangelical and other Protestant denominations, but also looked at us, our Catholic Church in America. While the study and the book are most concerned with Evangelical Protestant Churches, it does give us a picture of what is going on within our own Church.

They consider the “dechurched” as adults who once attended church but no longer do so and have no real desire, or motivation, to do so. Their findings show that there are about 40 million, 40 million, “dechurched” Christians, included Catholics, in America, and that this number is rapidly growing.

As I said, their findings show that this is not just a Catholic phenomenon but a phenomenon that is affecting all Christian denominations in our country. For instance, their study showed that the nation’s single largest Evangelical Protestant Church, the Southern Baptist Convention, has lost over 2 million, 2 million, members, representing about 17% of its membership, since just 2006. The study also showed that rate of people leaving that church is accelerating. Moreover, their findings show that the majority of people leaving the Southern Baptist Convention are not going to church elsewhere but simply are not going to church at all.

Some findings about the “dechurched” are interesting and similar for all denominations including our Catholic Church. For example, a large number of the “dechurched” are those who have moved and have not taken time to find a new Protestant church or Catholic parish. Another large number have decided to set other priorities on Sundays (children’s sports, for example). Another group just fell out of the practice of going to church during the Covid lockdown and just haven’t gotten back into it.

For the Catholic “dechurched” in particular, a large group are those who have stopped coming because they have been seduced by the Devil and no longer share our viewpoints on very important moral issues such as the sanctity of life, chastity, purity, gender identity, and sanctity of marriage. Sadly, we all know someone who has given into temptation and basically lost their Faith in High School or College and have stopped practicing their Catholic Faith because of it.

The findings revealed another interesting fact and a very hopeful fact. That is that many of the “dechurched” still think that church is important, even though they aren’t attending. Among “dechurched” Catholics, a full one-third (33%) responded that they think that church is still important and that they should be going to Mass, even though they are not.

This group provides a glimmer of hope and a window of opportunity. For, it may be just a simple invitation, such as: why don’t you come to Mass with me this weekend, to get someone to come back. As simple as that.

Simple, yet the invitation has to be personal. It cannot come from a TV commercial or a magazine advertisement or even from the pulpit. No, it has to be a personal invitation and then followed up with a genuine desire to help someone get back into the practice of our Catholic Religion. The Feast is here waiting for them. We are now God’s messengers extending the invitation.

This is important, because as the authors of “The Great Dechurching” note, we are not dealing with statistics, but we are dealing with souls. We are dealing with souls who have been called to the Feast and who are not coming.

We also know that we can do this, because the Angels and Saints of Heaven are rooting for us, and Our Blessed Savior is giving us the Grace to do so.

St. Joseph, Patron of the Church and our Patron, pray for us!

Fr. Michael J. Pawelko, Pastor.